Not only are you an excellent attorney, but a good person who truly cared about me and always did your best to help me. I am so grateful for being given a second chance.  —TomDave Shrager successfully lobbied for my felony charge to be completely withdrawn. His services were worth every dime. A highly personable, intelligent, and competent attorney, I would recommend Dave Shrager to my closest friends and family without hesitation.  —RonDave knows the system better than any lawyer in Pittsburgh due to his family's local and long-standing practice, and it was evident in the positive manner in which the judges, prosecutors, and law enforcement officers responded to Dave's arguments on my behalf.  —JimI cannot say thank you enough to David Shrager for all his help today! If it were not for this guy, I would no longer have a job or drivers license. So thanks again Dave, you're the best!  —BillI was in a bad place in my life...I was making bad decisions, which led to my having a really bad night and lots of legal trouble. I'm lucky I had Attorney David Shrager at my side. He helped guide me, with his legal expertise, through a very difficult time in my life.  —Tamika
Call 412-969-2540 to Speak Directly with Attorney David Shrager 24 HOURS A DAY, 7 DAYS A WEEK

Reasonable Doubt in Pennsylvania Criminal Trials

Being Arrested Does Not Mean You Will Be Convicted

When a person is arrested or charged with a crime in Pennsylvania and is required to go to trial, his or her guilt must be proven “beyond a reasonable doubt” by the prosecution in order for that person to be found guilty by a jury or judge.

Reasonable doubt is the standard of proof that must be met in criminal cases in order to convict a defendant. It is the highest standard of proof in the legal system, higher than the “preponderance of the evidence” standard in civil cases or “substantial proof” in CPS investigations.

What is Reasonable Doubt?

In criminal jury trials in PA, the judge bears the duty to instruct the jurors of what “reasonable doubt” means. Unlike some states Pennsylvania law does not require trial courts to use an exact pre-defined definition, and allows a court to “choose its own wording so long as the law is clearly, adequately, and accurately presented to the jury for its consideration.” (Commonwealth v. Rios, 920 A.2d 790 (Pa. 2007) citing Commonwealth v. Porter, 728 A.2d 890 (Pa. 1999)).

However, Pennsylvania does offer Pennsylvania Standard Jury Instructions that courts can use. Here is a definition of “reasonable doubt” contained therein:

Definition of “Reasonable Doubt” as Used in Pennsylvania Criminal Trials:

“A reasonable doubt is a doubt that would cause a reasonably careful and sensible person to hesitate before acting upon a matter of importance in his own affairs.” (7.01 PRESUMPTION OF INNOCENCE — BURDEN OF PROOF — REASONABLE DOUBT)

Creating Reasonable Doubt

Although reasonable doubt is the highest burden of proof, creating it often requires extensive pre-trial case preparation and focused cross-examination. Contrary to common myth, PA prosecutors are not required to prove guilt beyond any shadow of a doubt.

“Although the Commonwealth has the burden of proving that the defendant is guilty, this does not mean that the Commonwealth must prove its case beyond all doubt and to a mathematical certainty, nor must it demonstrate the complete impossibility of innocence.” (7.01 PRESUMPTION OF INNOCENCE — BURDEN OF PROOF — REASONABLE DOUBT)

Contact Shrager Defense Attorneys – Experienced Trial Attorneys in PA

Our Pittsburgh criminal trial attorneys thoroughly understand how to create reasonable doubt in trials. We have decades of experience and successful results defending clients in bench trials and jury trials throughout Western Pennsylvania. Call 412-567-6290 right now for a FREE initial legal consultation. Speak directly with David J. Shrager 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.